“The Judgement of Paris” – by Dee Schaad, Ceramic Artist

The Judgement of Paris is a famous story from Greek mythology that explains one of the causes of the Trojan War. Here’s the story:

At the wedding of Peleus and Thetis, everyone was invited except Eris, the goddess of discord. Angered by the slight, Eris threw a golden apple into the celebration inscribed “To the Fairest.” Three goddesses claimed the apple – Hera, Athena, and Aphrodite. Zeus refused to choose among them, fearing the consequences, so he appointed Paris, a Trojan mortal prince, as the judge.

Each goddess tried to persuade Paris by offering him a reward. Hera promised him political power and rulership over a vast empire. Athena offered unmatched wisdom and victory in battle. Aphrodite promised him the love of the most beautiful woman in the world, Helen. Paris awarded the golden apple to Aphrodite. The problem was that Helen was already married to Menelaus, king of Sparta. With Aphrodite’s help, Paris either abducted or eloped with Helen (different ancient sources tell it differently). This act led the Greek kings and heroes—including Agamemnon, Achilles, and Odysseus—to launch an expedition against Troy, beginning the Trojan War.

Symbolic Meaning
The Judgment of Paris has often been interpreted as representing the choice between power (Hera), wisdom and military glory (Athena), and love and desire (Aphrodite) – and how personal choices, especially those driven by desire, can have enormous and unforeseen consequences. The story became one of the most popular subjects in ancient Greek and later European art, often depicting Paris handing the golden apple to Aphrodite while the three goddesses stand before him. Here are some of the best-known artistic depictions of the Judgment of Paris, spanning several centuries:

1. Peter Paul Rubens – The Judgement of Paris (c. 1632–35)

  • One of the most famous Baroque interpretations.
  • Paris sits at the right holding the golden apple while Hermes presents Hera, Athena, and Aphrodite.
  • Rich color, dramatic movement, and idealized figures are characteristic of Rubens’s style.

2. Pierre-Auguste Renoir – The Judgment of Paris (1913–14)

  • A late Impressionist version with soft, luminous colors.
  • Renoir emphasizes harmony and beauty rather than the impending conflict of the Trojan War.

3. Another Renoir Variation (1913)

  • A more intimate composition showing Paris contemplating the three goddesses.
  • Reflects Renoir’s fascination with classical mythology and the female form.

4. Another Rubens Version (17th century)

  • Rubens painted several versions of this myth during his career.
  • His repeated return to the subject reflects its popularity in European art as an opportunity to depict the three goddesses in different poses.

The Judgment of Paris was one of the most popular mythological subjects in Western art. Besides Rubens and Renoir, notable versions were created by:

  • Sandro Botticelli (Renaissance)
  • Lucas Cranach the Elder (painted the subject more than 20 times)
  • Raphael (through influential drawings and engravings)
  • Paul Cézanne
  • Salvador Dalí
Dee Schaad was born and raised in Nebraska and has an MFA from Hixson-Leid College of Fine Arts at the University of Nebraska Lincoln. He taught ceramics at the University of Indianapolis for 39 years.  He was chairman of the Department of Art and Design from 1994 through 2010.  He currently is Professor Emeritus. His work is included in several books and in public and private collections and has been exhibited nationally.  His writing has appeared in a number of National publications and he has made several instructional videos for American Art Clay Company.  As a ceramist, his work covers a broad spectrum of ceramic processes.  He works in both stoneware and earthenware.  His work consists of large and small sculptural pieces and traditional, more functional vessel formatted objects.  Dee Schaad was named University of Indianapolis’ Teacher of the Year for 2006.  During the summer of 2007 he was awarded a Creative Renewal Arts Fellowship from the Arts Council of Indianapolis.  Dee Schaad had an installation at the Indianapolis International Airport  during 2014 and 2026. He continues to actively exhibit and conducts ceramic workshops throughout the United States.  In July of 2025, he was selected to be one of 50 over 50 by “Indianapolis Monthly” magazine.